Those who need a lot of coffee for a large family or small office know that 8-cup coffee makers are the best way to get the coffee you need, fast. However, there are a lot of models on the market today, priced in a variety of ways that can make it hard to tell if you’re making a good investment or one that you’ll soon regret.
While shopping online is supposed to make this easier, we all know that isn’t always the case. Tricky product descriptions can make it seem like you’re buying the next best thing, only to leave you having spent far too much for the subpar experience you end up getting.
If you want to get great value for your money, or just find a machine that works and gives you little trouble along the way, you’ve come to the right place. Our reviews are designed to show you the highlights and what’s not-so-great on each model so that you can find the one which is right for you.
|OXO On Barista 9 Cup Coffee Maker 8710100|
|Bonavita BV1900TS 8-Cup One-Touch Coffee Maker||6 lbs||4.6/5|
|Mr. Coffee BVMC-PSTX95||11 lbs||4.5/5|
|Proctor-Silex Coffee Maker 48351|
|Mixpresso 8 Cup Drip Coffee Maker||3 lbs||4.0/5|
The OXO On Barista 9 Cup Coffee Maker 8710100 is the model you’ll want to invest in if you’re looking for the best overall coffee maker with at least eight cups of capacity. This model can brew up to nine cups of coffee at once, making it large enough to keep a small office refreshed. It makes SCAA-certified coffee, which requires careful control of water temperature and replication of the pour-over method, which is impressive for an automatic coffee maker. It also comes with an easy-to-read LED interface, so you can see what step in the process is ongoing at any time. Plus, it comes with a programmable timer, so you can set this model to make coffee for you when you wake up.
This model also comes with a high-quality double-walled carafe which keeps the coffee warm for longer than with other cups. This model also keeps track of the coffee’s freshness, so you’ll know if you need to brew a fresh pot. Our only complaint is that the stopper leaks if you pull the carafe out to pour coffee during the pouring coffee. Still, if you need a high-capacity brewing machine, you’ll be happy with this model’s performance.
The Bonavita BV1900TS 8-Cup One-Touch Coffee Maker is one of the better coffee makers on our list when the maker itself is concerned. While many coffee makers have developed feature creep over the years and are needlessly complex, this model features one-touch operation. That’s right; all you have to do is turn it on and let it run. It’s also a relatively fast brewer, able to brew up to eight cups of coffee in just five minutes. During this time, it presoaks the grounds to ensure a rich, flavorful coffee made with water at the best temperature for brewing.
Most of the parts on this model are dishwasher safe. That saves you a lot of time when it comes time to clean this model. What keeps this model out of first place is its bad carafe. The lid design isn’t great, and it can be hard to get the last few drops of coffee out of the carafe. The good news is that you can order a different model carafe as a replacement, but that drives up the price. If the included carafe were to be improved, it would be easy to rank this model higher on our list.
The Mr. Coffee BVMC-PSTX95 is another decent model for making up to 8 cups of coffee at once. This model solves some of the pain points that other models cause while introducing a few new ones of its own. The best thing about this model is its high-quality water filtration, which reduces chlorine and other contaminants to deliver a great-tasting coffee. It also comes with great cleaning options, including an automatic cleaning cycle which requires little work on the user’s part. It also comes with Grab-A-Cup Auto Pause, which is a fancy way of saying that this machine stops adding coffee to the carafe when you remove it to pour yourself a cup, reducing waste and cleanup.
However, this model produces a lot of steam. In some cases, it’s enough to damage the cabinets or other materials nearby. It also doesn’t produce the strongest coffee. If you’re looking for a rich, flavorful cup, you’ll probably want to go with a different machine, as this one focuses more on quantity than quality. Overall, this machine isn’t a terrible buy, but most people will be able to get a better deal for the price.
If you’re looking for a coffee maker that can provide a ton of coffee at once without having to break the bank to do so, then the Proctor-Silex Coffee Maker 48351 could be just what you’re looking for. This model comes with a ten-cup capacity, and it also automatically detects when the carafe has been removed and stops brewing so that you can get a cup for yourself before the end of the brew cycle without making a mess. The illuminated on/off switch means you can start a pot of coffee without turning the lights on and waking everyone up, and the dishwasher-safe parts make cleanup fast and easy.
You can also get this model for a fraction of what you’d pay for the top three models on our list. That’s why this model is the best overall value for the money. However, it does suffer from some quality control problems, and you may find yourself returning your unit to get one that functions correctly. If this model was of more consistent quality, we’d be happy to rank it higher. Until then, it’s still a good choice for those looking for an inexpensive, high-capacity machine.
The Mixpresso 8 Cup Drip Coffee Maker is the model for people who need more coffee without wanting to spend an arm and a leg, and who don’t want to have to dedicate more counter space to their coffee maker. The best thing about this coffee maker is that it can produce eight cups of coffee, but it’s not any larger than a four-cup coffee maker, making it great for people with limited space in their kitchens. It also comes with a reusable filter basket, which will save you a lot of money on filters in the long run, and since it’s removable, it’s easy to clean, as well.
This model isn’t that expensive, which will make it attractive to bargain hunters. However, it’s not a perfect brewer. The hot plate isn’t hot enough to keep your coffee warm long-term, and while it doesn’t run the risk of burning it, you’ll probably have to microwave your coffee, especially if you like it hot. Programming this machine isn’t straightforward, so not everyone is able to ultimately do it. Still, if you’re looking for a cheap model and don’t mind reheating your coffee, this model could be a decent overall fit.
When it comes to buying an 8-cup coffee maker, it’s important to consider the quality of the brew, and the ease of use.
Falling short in either of these areas will lead you to a bad experience, no matter how much or little you paid for the machine. When it comes to brew quality, pay attention to the temperature to which the water is heated, as well as any possible certifications which the machine may have that testify to its brewing capabilities.
You’ll also want to get a machine that’s easy to use. In most cases, that means getting a brewer that has parts that are dishwasher-safe. That way, you won’t have to do a lot of cleanup by hand.
Our other coffee maker buyer’s guides:
The OXO On Barista 9 Cup Coffee Maker 8710100 is our favorite model due to its production of SCAA-certified coffee, its great LED interface, and its programmable timer. In second is the Bonavita BV1900TS 8-Cup One-Touch Coffee Maker, which features one-touch operation, dishwasher-safe parts, and fast brewing, though its bad carafe drops it to second place. The Mr. Coffee BVMC-PSTX95 has great water filtration and great cleaning options, but its excessive steam production and relatively weak coffee make it the wrong choice for most people. The Proctor-Silex Coffee Maker 48351 comes with auto pause and serve and dishwasher-safe parts. Since you can get it at a fantastic price, it’s the best overall value for the money on our list. In last place is the Mixpresso 8 Cup Drip Coffee Maker which does come with a nice reusable filter basket and a compact body but suffers from complicated programming and a cold warming plate.
We hope that our reviews and buyer’s guide have taught you everything you need to know about eight-cup coffee makers and have helped you find the model which is right for you.
Table of Contents
What’s the Best Kind of Water for Coffee? (It Makes a BIG Difference!)
3 Tips & Tricks For Switching To Black Coffee
Best Single Serve Coffee Makers 2020 – Top Picks & Reviews
Best Electric Kettle for Coffee Brewing 2020 – Top Picks & Reviews
Best Starbucks K-Cups 2020 – Top Flavors Reviewed