Best Colombian Coffee 2019 – Reviews & Top Picks

Last Updated: by: Amanda T

colombian coffee plantation

With a landscape dominated by small family farms, Colombia is home to nearly half a million coffee-growing families. As the world’s third-largest producer of coffee, it’s also the top producer of arabica coffee. With an ideal climate prime for producing luscious beans, coffee isn’t just a crop in Colombia –  it’s a way of life.

For clarification, there are two species of coffee beans: Coffea arabica and Coffea robusta. Arabica beans, in general, have a mild, sweet taste caressed with light undertones and a pleasant acidity. Colombia produces 100% arabica beans. With the vast production coming from Colombia, how do you choose? We’re providing our top ten reviews of our favorite Colombian coffees to give you some guidance.

Comparison of our Favorites

ModelPriceRoastEditor Rating
Volcanica Coffee Colombian Supremo
Volcanica Coffee
(Top Pick)

Check Price
Medium4.70/5
Cafe Don Pablo Gourmet Colombian
Cafe Don Pablo

Check Price
Medium-Dark4.55/5
AmazonFresh Colombia
AmazonFresh Colombia

Check Price
Medium4.50/5
Juan Valdez Organic Colombian
JUAN VALDEZ Organic Colombian

Check Price
Medium4.40/5
Blackwelder Coffee Colombian
Blackwelder Coffee

Check Price
Medium-Dark4.20/5

Best Colombian Coffees – Reviewed in 2019

1. Volcanica Coffee Colombian Supremo Coffee – Top Pick

Volcanica Coffee

Volcanica Colombian Supremo Coffee is grown in the volcanic soils of the Colombian Andes and imported to Atlanta, Georgia, where these beans are roasted to a medium finish. This rich coffee has a delicious aroma and a smooth finish that will start your day off right.

However, with its full-bodied profile, it may taste more like a dark roast. For those looking to satisfy a true medium taste, this one will be overpowering.

Although this gourmet brand is expensive, this brand may appeal to the environmentally-minded as it is Fair Trade and Rainforest Alliance certified.

Pros
  • Smooth flavor
  • Nutty aroma
  • Pleasant acidity
  • Fair trade & Rainforest Alliance certified
Cons
  • Expensive

2. Cafe Don Pablo Gourmet Colombian Whole Bean Coffee – The Runner-Up

Cafe Don Pablo

Our runner-up is Cafe Don Pablo Gourmet Colombian Coffee. These beans are roasted to order in small batches, allowing the roasters to infuse your beans with a little love. This pick delivers a true medium-to-dark roast with low acidity and a cocoa-toned finish. The sweet aroma will have smiling into your cup.

If you know Colombian coffee as having a mild flavor, this roast may sing with a bitter note due to the roasting profile. Delivering a sharp bite, it may taste burnt if you’re not accustomed to a darker roast.

As an budget purchase, it’s a good value for the money.

Pros
  • Economical
  • Full-bodied
  • Smooth delivery
  • Chocolate finish
  • Low acidity
  • Citrus notes
  • USDA certified for organic production
Cons
  • Bitter aftertaste

3. AmazonFresh Colombia Whole Bean Coffee

AmazonFresh Colombia

AmazonFresh Colombia Coffee offers a light citrus aroma to start our day and will have you refilling quickly. It has sweet notes of chocolate and brown sugar with low acidity. With a favorable price and a flavor-rich conveyance, this is a good value for the money.

This medium roast has balanced flavor, yet does land on the softer side of spectrum. For those looking for a bolder, medium roast, this choice may not satisfy the craving.

Priced for those on a budget, this pick is noted as being an everyday choice for many. If you’re seeking a go-to blend, subscribe-and-save is an option that will leave a few more dollars in your wallet.

Pros
  • Economical
  • Citrus aroma
  • Full-bodied
  • Smooth finish
  • Low acidity
  • Money-back guarantee
Cons
  • Too mild
  • Muted flavor

4. Juan Valdez Organic Colombian Fairtrade Coffee

JUAN VALDEZ Organic Colombian

Known to many as the father and face of Colombian coffee, Juan Valdez has a reputation for unmatched consistency and broad appeal to the masses. This Juan Valdez Organic Colombian Fairtrade Coffee is a medium roast with a strong aroma that is sure to get you moving in the morning. It has little acidity and bitterness making this a perfect match with the straight black coffee drinker.

If you’re looking for a robust profile, you may be disappointed with the milder flavor of this medium roast, especially with its higher price tag. If you are underwhelmed by the flavor, at least it’s available in a ten-ounce size.

Pros
  • Pleasant acidity
  • Strong aroma
  • Rich flavor
  • Organic and Fair Trade certified
Cons
  • Slightly pricey
  • Too mild

5. Blackwelder Coffee Whole Bean Colombian Coffee

Blackwelder Coffee

If you’re looking to wake up to a sweet aroma, welcome to our next choice, Blackwelder Medium Dark Roast Colombian Coffee. It’s a family-owned business of Californian micro artisans roasting who offer same-day shipping. This pick is a single-origin coffee noted as a smooth breakfast coffee. It has chocolate and orange tinges combined with enough strength to have you coming back for a refill.

For the coffee lover who desires a bold, strong flavor with the added bite, this sweet coffee may not hit the right spots. This brand is also on the pricier side of one-pound purchases; however, if you do like this choice, it is less expensive than the five-pound purchase.

Pros
  • Sweet aroma
  • Rich flavor
  • Balanced acidity
  • Roasts day of shipping
Cons
  • Slightly expensive
  • Too mild

6. Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC Dark Colombian Supremo Coffee

Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC

With a darkness similar to a French roast, Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC, Dark Colombian Supremo Coffee, delivers a robust body with a smoky flavor and no harsh edges. This budget-friendly choice is noted as having undertones of honey and cherry.

If you prefer a bit of a milder tone to your cup of Joe, this true dark roast will not fit the bill. However, if you’re a French roast lover, this bean may be more to your liking. Although at an affordable price, the smallest size is a two-pound bag.

This brand prides itself on the quality of care and integrity when it comes to sourcing.  Noting the company’s commitment to the next generation, it’s certified Direct Trade, Fair Trade, Rainforest Alliance, and USDA Organic.

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Robust body
  • Sweet notes
  • USDA Organic & Fair Trade certified
Cons
  • Smoky flavor

7. Don Francisco’s Colombia Supremo Whole Bean Coffee

Don Franciscos Colombia Supremo

As a brand with 140 years under its belt, we have Don Francisco’s Colombia Supremo Whole Bean coffee. If you’re searching for that satisfying cup of “just right” medium roasted coffee, our number seven review may be where you land in your search. With a sweet aroma and tangy notes, it provides a bold, rich flavor.

If you’re a straight black coffee lover, this one may seem a little harsh and have a sour aftertaste. However, with the affordable price, it’s a popular choice for everyday coffee lovers.  Take note that if you decide to try these beans, the smallest size available is 32 ounces.

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Sweet aroma
  • Tangy notes
Cons
  • Sour aftertaste
  • Slightly acidic

8. Koffee Kult Colombian Huila Fresh Coffee Beans

Koffee Kult Colombian Huila

Koffee Kult Colombian Huila has an excellent aroma and works well for espresso. With a sweet finish and no bitterness, this is brand has a cult following. It’s a bold choice with a medium roast. If you do decide you love this option, you may feel the urge to do a hula dance, but if you’re curious about the name, Huila, pronounced [wee – la] refers to the Colombian region where the beans are grown.

Some coffeeholics have noted that this roast is too light and packs a weak flavor. As one of our most expensive picks, its price keeps this one further down on our list.

Customer service is a high priority for this family-run business and it hasn’t gone unnoticed. As for the price, this coffee comes with a money-back guarantee, in case it doesn’t suit your taste.

Pros
  • Bold aroma
  • Smooth flavor
  • Money-back guarantee
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Muted flavor

9. Peet’s Coffee Colombia Luminosa Ground – Best Ground Coffee Pick

Peets Coffee, Colombia Luminosa

For quick and easy brewing, Peet’s Colombia Luminosa is our choice for best ground Colombian coffee. “Luminosa” means bright or full of light, and this gentle roast lacks a bitter bite – an ideal choice for a smooth breakfast coffee. This selection has a slightly sweet flavor that is not overpowering.

On the downside, it lacks the nuttiness that is typically expected with a light roast. Although we consider it the best ground Colombian coffee choice, it’s also the most expensive on our list and comes in a pack of two 12-ounce bags.

Pros
  • Mild flavor
  • Smooth finish
  • Delicate aroma
Cons
  • Expensive

10. Cubico Coffee Colombia

Cubico Coffee

From a single source, Cubico Colombia coffee is grown in the mountain region, Narino, located in southwest Colombia. This coffee producer has 15 farms and is a member of the “Million Pesos” Program that’s unique to Colombia. In the program, producers are paid double the price for high-quality coffees.

This medium roast features an intense citrus-tinged flavor with sweet undertones. With its complex profile, it may not meet the expectations of a coffee lover who wants the chocolate hit of a hearty, robust flavor.

Pros
  • Unique profile
  • Rich aroma
Cons
  • Slightly expensive
  • Acidic
  • Not suitable for those with sensitive stomachs

Factors to Consider When Picking

Ultimately, whether you purchase whole bean or ground coffee will come down to personal preference and lifestyle. Buying whole beans and waiting to grind them until you’re going to brew them provides the freshest and most flavorful cup of coffee. It’s a completely different experience. A few things you want to consider when choosing Colombian coffee beans are: origin, roast, and company ethics.

Origin

Understanding the different regions in Colombia will help you better understand the coffee bean. Different regions have different altitudes, temperatures, wet and dry seasons, and harvest times. With a wide array of distinctive coffees available, understanding the differences will ensure you find the bean you’ll love. Do your research and learn a little geography in Colombia.

Roast

Colombia produces 100% arabica beans which is considered a superior bean. Generally speaking, Colombian coffee is known for its sweeter taste, lesser caffeine content, and stronger acidity. The final flavor of a bean will depend on the region where they were grown and how the beans are roasted. As with any coffee, you may have to play trial and error. A lighter roast may be too mild, a dark roast may be too bitter, and everything in between is considered a variation of a medium roast. So just have fun with the process!

Company Ethics

With the creation of the National Federation of Coffee Growers of Colombia in 1927, the coffee growers’ interests are protected nationally and internationally. This organization was borne out of the growers’ need to improve their quality of life and ensure coffee is grown sustainably. If environmental ethics is important to you, many companies are offering organic and fair trade certified options and support quality practices to benefit the growers. Read more about the companies to determine which ones will align with your ethics.

Conclusion

If you’ve never tried Colombian coffee and decide you want to add a little culture to the start of your day, hopefully, you have a better idea of where to start with our reviews our top ten choices. Our top choice is Volcanica Coffee Colombian Supremo with its smooth flavor and nutty aroma. Our runner-up is Cafe Don Pablo Gourmet Colombian Medium-Dark Whole Bean as an economical purchase with a chocolatey finish. Lastly, our best ground coffee pick is Peet’s Coffee Colombia Luminosa with a mild flavor and delicate aroma. Whichever one you choose, let everyone know what you think. Leaving a review is the best way to share your coffee experience. While we all have different preferences, every coffee lover wants to know what you think. Keep it fun and happy brewing!


Featured image credit: USA-Reiseblogger, Pixabay