Best SCAA Certified Coffee Makers 2019 – Reviews & Buying Guide

a SCAA certified coffee machine

If you want coffee like the coffee at an expensive shop, you need a SCAA-certified coffee maker. That certification is the one used by machines in coffee shops to produce bold flavors, and many users report that they just make flat-out better coffee in every category.

However, it’s easy to say that your coffee maker meets those standards. Making a coffee maker that people like using is another task altogether. Finding the perfect combination of these two features may sound impossible, but we’ve done the hard work for you already.

These reviews of the best SCAA-certified coffee makers are designed to show you how easy or hard each machine is to use, and how well they brew coffee. That way, you can find a model that will get you the coffee you want with as little fuss as possible.

Our Favorites (Last updated: 2019)

ModelPriceWeightEditor Rating
Technivorm Moccamaster 59616 KBG Coffee Brewer
Technivorm Moccamaster 59616 KBG Coffee Brewer(Top Pick)

Check Price
6 lbs4.8/5
OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker
OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker

Check Price
8 lbs
4.6/5
Bonavita BV1900TS 8-Cup One-Touch Coffee Maker
Bonavita BV1900TS 8-Cup One-Touch Coffee Maker(Best for the Money)

Check Price
6 lbs4.5/5
Cuisinart CPO-850 Pour Over Coffee Brewer
Cuisinart CPO-850 Pour Over Coffee Brewer

Check Price
9 lbs4.2/5
BUNN HB Heat N Brew Programmable Coffee Maker
BUNN HB Heat N Brew Programmable Coffee Maker

Check Price
9 lbs4.0/5

5 Best SCAA Approved Coffee Makers – Reviews

1. Technivorm Moccamaster KBG SCAA Certified Coffee Brewer – Top Pick

Technivorm Moccamaster 59616 KBG Coffee Brewer

The Technivorm Moccamaster 59616 KBG Coffee Brewer is the best overall SCAA-certified coffee maker. It’s available in twenty different colors, so you can make a statement with your coffee maker regardless of the décor of your kitchen. It has a drip-stop feature, so you can remove the carafe to pour yourself a cup of coffee, and it will stop brewing until you return it. Plus, this model is designed to heat water to between 196 and 205 degrees Fahrenheit, which is necessary for the SCAA certification.

This machine comes with a five-year warranty, which is much longer than you can typically get on a coffee maker. That’s a great sign that the manufacturer truly believes in this product and is willing to stand behind it if something goes wrong. The only thing that could make it easier to use is a removable water reservoir. As things stand right now, you have to bring the water to the coffee maker. Still, this is a great coffee maker that will make strong coffee most people will love.

Pros
  • Tons of colors
  • Drip-stop
  • Controlled brewing temperature
  • Five-year warranty
Cons
  • Water reservoir is not removable

2. OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker – The Runner-Up

OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker

The OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker is another one of our favorite SCAA-certified coffee makers. It has one of the tightest temperature ranges, which actually exceeds SCAA requirements. Since the water is heated to between 197.6 and 204.8 degrees, you’ll know that you’re getting the maximum possible flavor out of your coffee. The clean, stainless steel body will help it fit in well with most kitchens. You can program this machine to make between two and nine cups of coffee, regardless of how much water is in its tank, and you can program it to brew up to 24 hours later.

The sleek, double-walled carafe keeps coffee warm for a while after it’s brewed, without the requirement of using a hot plate. That means the coffee won’t get burned. However, the carafe can be hard to clean since it has a relatively small opening. If there were a way to clean this model more easily, we could see it taking first. However, it makes exquisite coffee, and if that’s all you’re looking for, you’ll be very happy with this coffee maker.

Pros
  • Very tight temperature range
  • Sleek look
  • Programmable
  • Double-walled carafe
Cons
  • Carafe can be hard to clean

3. Bonavita 8-Cup SCAA Approved Coffee Maker – Best for the Money

Bonavita BV1900TS 8-Cup One-Touch Coffee Maker

The Bonavita BV1900TS 8-Cup One-Touch Coffee Maker does a number of things very well. Chief among those is making coffee. This machine holds to the SCAA-certified 195-205-degree brewing temperature, which results in an excellent cup of coffee. The pre-infusion mode allows you to alter the flavor of your coffee. Another big plus is that it’s extremely simple to operate. Just flip a single switch, and you’ll be brewing away.

However, what really sets this one apart is its price. You can pick it up for less than half of what you’d pay for our top-ranked choice. Given its clear value in other areas, it’s easy to label this machine the best value here. If you’re looking for an affordable SCAA-certified coffee machine, this one is a safe bet. The one thing that could be added to help this model rise on our list would be the option to program it, though that would detract from its overall simplicity. This is the coffee maker for people who want great coffee and a great deal.

Pros
  • One-touch brew operation
  • Controlled brewing temperature
  • Pre-infusion mode
  • Great price
Cons
  • Lacks programming

4. Cuisinart CPO-850 Pour-Over Coffee Brewer (SCAA-Certified)

Cuisinart CPO-850 Pour Over Coffee Brewer with Thermal Carafe

The Cuisinart CPO-850 Pour Over Coffee Brewer gives you more options than most SCAA-certified brewing machines. It has a normal brewing mode that meets the guidelines set out by that organization, but also includes an “extra hot” mode for those who like their coffee really hot. Also included in this machine are not one, not two, but three different flavor profiles. You can brew it mild, medium, or bold to suit your tastes. This machine has a stainless steel thermal carafe. If you want to keep your coffee hot for longer, but don’t want to worry about burning it over a hotplate, this coffee maker has just what you need.

Unfortunately, we can’t rank it any higher than fourth due to its durability concerns. The screen is especially prone to breaking, and this model doesn’t have a stellar reputation when it comes to longevity. Some units reportedly give out in under a year. Cuisinart’s customer service can also be tricky to deal with, which makes durability problems that much worse. This machine makes great, and highly customizable, coffee, but given its multiple problems, it’s not necessarily a good buy for the price.

Pros
  • Good temperature control
  • Flavor control
  • Thermal carafe
Cons
  • Some durability concerns
  • Tricky customer service

5. BUNN Heat N Brew Programmable SCAA-Approved Coffeemaker

BUNN HB Heat N Brew Programmable Coffee Maker

The BUNN HB Heat N Brew Programmable Coffee Maker is certified by the SCAA, but that designation alone doesn’t necessarily mean it creates an experience that people will enjoy. On the plus side, it is programmable, so you can set it up in advance and wake up to the smell of hot coffee. It also comes with a hot plate, so you’ll be able to keep coffee warm for up to two hours before it turns itself off automatically. BUNN gives this model a three-year warranty, so it comes with peace of mind that it won’t give out unexpectedly.

Unfortunately, the carafe is underwhelming. While it is shatter-resistant, it tends to drip while you pour, which can make a big mess and is a general pain to deal with. It’s also not the best on our list when it comes to flavor extraction. Other machines do a better job of getting the maximum taste out of your beans, expensive or not. This brewer might be a good choice for those who don’t care too much about flavor, but that’s not typically what you’re hoping for when you buy a SCAA-certified unit.

Pros
  • Programmable
  • Hot plate
  • Three-year warranty
Cons
  • Drippy carafe
  • Underwhelming flavor extraction

Buyer’s Guide

The SCAA certification

After reading about these coffee makers, you may be wondering what makes the SCAA certification so special.

Technically speaking, the “golden cup” standard requires that the Total Dissolved Solids represent 1.15 to 1.35 percent so that the solubles extraction yield is 18 to 22 percent.

Does that sound like a bunch of gibberish?

That’s okay. We know that doesn’t make a lot of sense to those who aren’t actively making their own coffee, so we’ll break it down for you.

Essentially, the standard wants to make sure that the ratio of coffee to water in your cup falls within certain ranges that are set in a way that’s supposed to maximize flavor. There are certain best practices used by people and machines to ensure that those ratios are met.

Some people may like coffee that falls outside this range better, but the standard does produce coffee that most coffee drinkers really like.

For brewing machines, the water needs to be heated to within five degrees of 200 degrees Fahrenheit, or a range of 195 to 205 degrees. The coffee machines are supposed to be designed to produce turbulence, so that all coffee grounds make contact with the water, leaving none dry and maximizing flavor.

There are other things that go into the standard that aren’t dependent on the machine, such as the water quality, and the types of filters used, though that’s something that the user controls.

When it comes to coffee makers that meet SCAA standards, look for models that heat the water to between 195 and 205 degrees Fahrenheit, and also produce turbulence so that all coffee grounds are used in production of the coffee.

Programmability

Something that can make or break a coffee maker for many people is whether it can be programmed. If you want to wake up to coffee, confirm that a machine can be programmed before you buy. Otherwise, you’ll have to wait for the coffee in the morning and put the materials together before your first cup, which can be an unpleasant experience.

Some machines make programmability easier than others. One on our list does it with a simple twist of a dial. Others require you to go through a series of sub-menus, which isn’t a quick and easy experience.

If you’re looking to save on the price, you can typically get a machine that brews well, but costs much less than a similar one with programming. It’s a good first feature to drop from your list if you want to save some money.

Thermal carafe vs. hot plate

Many people who are serious about their coffee’s flavor will spurn machines with hot plates. The reason is simple. Hot plates can burn coffee, altering its flavor over time, even as it’s kept warm. That means your cups later in the day won’t be as good as the ones you got while the coffee was fresh.

Hot plates that are left on all day can also present a potential fire risk, which is why many machines now automatically turn off after two or four hours. In some instances, that means the coffee won’t be kept warm as long as you’d like.

Thermal carafes are an alternative for keeping coffee hot. The area between the inner and outer wall is vacuum-sealed so that a majority of the heat is kept inside the carafe. While some thermal carafes work very well, many do not. If you’re looking to keep coffee warmer for longer, you’re still probably better off with a hot plate. Even better, let it cool down and reheat it in a microwave when you’re ready to drink.

Brewing options

Another area where SCAA-certified coffee makers differ is the brewing options. Some allow you to make a different number of cups at a time through software settings, while others brew strictly based on the amount of water you’ve filled them with. SCAA-certified coffee requires a specific ratio of coffee grounds to water, so if you’re changing how much coffee you’re making, you need to change the number of grounds you’re using, too.

However, it is nice to be able to fill the water reservoir when you need to and get the number of cups you want with a simple software setting.

Consider the temperature settings as well. Some machines allow you to brew hotter or colder than SCAA standards, so if you already know your taste falls outside those boundaries, you’ll want to get one of those. Likewise, some machines allow for stronger or weaker coffee with a software setting, which again falls outside SCAA settings, but can lead to a more satisfying cup of coffee.

Our other coffee maker reviews:

–> Which 4-cup coffee maker is our favorite?

–> How does a drip coffee maker compare to a percolator?

–> Which single-serve coffee maker do we recommend?

Conclusion

The Technivorm Moccamaster 59616 KBG Coffee Brewer is our favorite due to its variety in appearance, drip-stop feature, and a massive five-year warranty. The OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker comes in second with its very tight temperature range, sleek look, and programmability, though its carafe is hard to clean. Next is the Bonavita BV1900TS 8-Cup One-Touch Coffee Maker, which has one-touch operation, a controlled brewing temperature, and pre-infusion mode. Its price is so great that it earns the title of best value for the money. The Cuisinart CPO-850 Pour-Over Coffee Brewer comes with multiple temperatures and flavor controls. Durability concerns and tricky customer service drop it to fourth place. The BUNN HB Heat N Brew Programmable Coffee Maker has a three-year warranty, but its drippy carafe and underwhelming flavor extraction leave it in the last place.

We hope our guide and reviews have brought you one step closer to obtaining the coffee of your dreams, and have led you to a maker that will keep you brewing happily for years.

Editor Rating: